What Are the Five Worst* Best Picture Oscar Winners From the Last 25 Years?

Share on twitter Tweet
Share on facebook Share

Trivial Diversions

What Are the Five Worst* Best Picture Oscar Winners From the Last 25 Years?

What Are the Five Worst* Best Picture Oscar Winners From the Last 25 Years?

*Worst means “worst-reviewed as per the aggregate approval rating of critics as listed on Rotten Tomatoes,” not “actually, objectively worst,” because there’s no way of objectively determining the relative quality of movies. And a great big PPPHHHHBBBBTTTT to awards season.

5. Braveheart — 78% approval rating

It’s like the Academy somehow always knew about Mel Gibson.

braveheart

4. Gladiator–76% approval rating

Hey, as Russell Crowe movies go, it’s no Winter’s Tale.

gladiator

3. A Beautiful Mind–75% approval rating

Russell Crowe is cursed, I tell you! Cursed!

a beautiful mind

2. Crash — 75% approval rating

Yup–the notorious Crash, whose Oscar victory has led to endless thinkpieces and general gnashing of teeth in the ten years since it beat out the favored Brokeback Mountain, is only the second worst-reviewed movie to take home the Best Picture statuette since 1990. (It has the same approval rating as A Beautiful Mind, but slightly more reviews, so it gets bumped up.) Congrats, director Paul Haggis?

crash

And the ultimate winner-loser is:

1. Forrest Gump–72% approval rating

Yeeeeeahhhh, this one hasn’t aged well. By comparison, look at fellow nominees Pulp Fiction (94%), Quiz Show (96%), and The Shawshank Redemption (91%). Oh, and Four Weddings and a Funeral, which has a 95% approval rating. I didn’t even realize it was a Best Picture nominee. I’m confused, too.

forrest gump

Related topics Academy Awards, Oscars
Next post Previous post

Your reaction to this post?

  • LOL

    0

  • Money

    0

  • Cool

    0

  • Fail

    0

  • Cry

    0

  • Geek

    0

  • Angry

    0

  • WTF

    0

  • Crazy

    0

  • Love

    0

You may also like

2961 Views
12 Things To Know About The One-Two Punch Of Yojimbo And Sanjuro
Pop Culture

12 Things To Know About The One-Two Punch Of Yojimbo And Sanjuro

By the 1960s, Akira Kurosawa was becoming  force in international

2037 Views
13 Cult Classics That Roger Ebert Absolutely Loathed
Movies

13 Cult Classics That Roger Ebert Absolutely Loathed

The lack of an Oscar nomination for Roger Ebert doc Life Itself has been something of a head-scratcher, but I've figured out the reasoning behind it: How could the Academy possibly honor a man who only gave Mighty Morphin Power Rangers: The Movie ("about as close as you can get to absolute nothing and still have a product to project on the screen.") one star? It's shameful. Here are thirteen other beloved (beloved by some, at least) films that the late critic gave two thumbs way, way down.

1472 Views
WHO DIRECTED THAT?!? 7 Movies With Surprising Directors
Movies

WHO DIRECTED THAT?!? 7 Movies With Surprising Directors

Some of the most celebrated directors in film history are